Young Christian Woman Allegedly Abducted in Pakistan
Muslims said to employ various ruses; forced conversion, marriage feared.
LAHORE, Pakistan (Compass Direct News) - A Muslim man tricked a 19-year-old Christian woman into leaving her house here on April 1, and he and a car full of friends took her away, according to her family.
Sonia Mohan's family said they fear the Muslim, Ali Raza, will force her to convert to Islam and marry him. Raza came to their home in Lahore's Nishtar Colony claiming that her brother, Johnson Parvaiz, wanted to see her outside, Parvaiz said.
"Sonia would not have gone with them if he hadn't told her that I wanted to see her," Parvaiz said. "Ali Raza came to our home and told Sonia that I had asked for her, and she went out of the house with him. They had parked a vehicle outside and left, and afterwards we never heard from her."
Get Our Latest News for FREE
He said his sister's cell phone remained off for two days. When it began to ring again they called repeatedly, and finally a man answered the phone and then handed it to Mohan. Parvaiz said she told him not to call her, that she was very happy and that they should not try to find her.
"It was obvious from her voice that she had been forced to say that," Parvaiz said. "I fear that she will first be converted to Islam, and then married, and then it will become impossible for us to see her again."
Initially police were unwilling to register the family's complaint, he said. Only after the family enlisted the help of the All Pakistan Minorities Alliance (APMA) did police begin searching for Raza and Mohan.
Parvaiz added that Raza and his friends had previously told her to convert to Islam, saying that because she was beautiful she did not deserve to live as a lowly Christian. Raza and Mohan had no prior contact except that Raza had harassed his sister that one time, he said; her family complained to his parents, who live in the area.
Parvaiz added that Raza worked in a factory called Combined Fabrics, where he had a reputation of harassing Christian women. Since the alleged abduction he has been missing from work.
Nishtar Colony Station House Officer Munawar Doggar told Compass that it did not appear that Mohan, who along with the rest of her family belongs to the American Reformed Presbyterian Church, went with Raza willingly. He said he had delayed registering a case on behalf of Mohan's family only because Raza's family had filed a complaint that Raza himself had been abducted.
After speaking with Compass, however, Doggar said he would file a First Information Report imminently.
"I want to fully investigate the matter so that no injustice is done to any party," he said. "But the family of the girl should now come to the police station and surely their FIR will be registered."
On the day of the kidnapping, Raza's uncle, Zaffar Jamil, filed a complaint that Raza himself had been abducted as a smokescreen to delay police in pursuing the abduction of Mohan, Parvaiz said.
"In this way, the police would reject my police complaint, saying, 'Raza was abducted, so how could he abduct Sonia?'" Parvaiz said.
In his uncle Jamil's complaint to police, Jamil had said that two men identified only as Fahad and Almas - friends of Raza present in the waiting car when Raza allegedly kidnapped Mohan - were the ones who likely abducted Raza.
Compass has obtained a copy of Jamil's complaint. He crafted it in such a way that he can withdraw it at any point, and he says he had only a suspicion about the abduction of Raza and the identity of the supposed culprits. Otherwise police would quickly determine that Fahad and Almas had not abducted Raza, and the tactic to delay justice would be short-lived, Parvaiz said.
APMA Chief Organizer in Punjab Province Khalid Gill told Compass that previously Fahad had employed duplicitous tactics to marry a Christian woman in Youhanabad, Lahore, and that for that reason Raza had sought Fahad's help in tricking Mohan into going with him.
Gill said that in such kidnapping cases, police often delay investigations until after abducted women get pregnant, after which legally it is nearly impossible for courts to return them to their families.
"That is the reason that APMA has been asking for revision of the family laws, and that in such cases where such tactics have been used, the marriage should be declared void so that the girl returns to the family and starts living her life from where it was interrupted," Gill said.
Jamil and Raza's brother, Nasir Dilawar, and Dilawar's wife Majidan, along with Raza's brother Muhammad Asif, have assured Mohan's family that she will be returned soon, but that promise also was only at attempt to forestall legal action, Parvaiz said.
He added that the fact that Raza and his accomplices felt it necessary to employ the ruses to delay police investigations was further evidence that Mohan and Raza had no prior relationship.
The family fears that the longer her return is delayed, the more likely that she will become pregnant or get intimidated into giving a statement in court that she went willingly due to her captors' threats that her father or brothers will be killed if she refuses, Parvaiz said.
